State Nursing Home Quality Improvement Programs: Site Visit and Synthesis Report. Impact of Iowa's Quality Improvement Programs on Quality of Care/Quality of Life


No evaluation of the impact of these programs has been made to date. Some decrease in the number of deficiencies has been noted in recent years, but it is not clear that there is any connection between the quality improvement programs and the number of deficiencies cited. Although there are statistics available on how many people access the website, there is no information as to whether these users are consumers, policymakers, researchers, or others. It is not known how the Report Cards affect consumer choices or facility quality. With only one nursing home in the state having applied to participate in the Quality-Based Inspections program, it is clear that this program, as implemented, has not had any impact on the quality of care or the quality of life for Iowa nursing home residents. Based on informal polling of providers, Dr. Tooman reported that the majority of providers have at least looked at the best practices, and he has anecdotal evidence that some facilities have adopted the best practices of other facilities.

Ombudsman did not note any significant improvement in care since the implementation of the quality improvement programs. They explained that, for example, the Governor's Award program, "It's nice and warm and fuzzy, but we don't really know that it improves care." They went on to say that these programs have focused on the average and above average facilities and have not raised the standards or done enough to deal with the poor performers. They believe that many of the best practices just represent activities that the facility should be performing routinely and do not represent exceptional care. They also believe that many facilities do not nominate themselves for a Best Practice Award believing that these practices are simply, "part of their job."

One provider representative stated that, "nothing improves quality more than reimbursement." She went on to say that although award programs are going in the right direction--the number one and two issues for facilities are reimbursement and consultative assistance and that these are the issues that facilities would like addressed--the "rest of this is just window dressing."

View full report


"statenh.pdf" (pdf, 822.35Kb)

Note: Documents in PDF format require the Adobe Acrobat Reader®. If you experience problems with PDF documents, please download the latest version of the Reader®