Standards for Privacy of Individually Identifiable Health Information. Final Privacy Rule Preamble.. Section 164.512(c) - Disclosures about Victims of Abuse, Neglect, or Domestic Violence

12/28/2000

The NPRM did not include a paragraph specifically addressing covered entities' disclosures of protected health information regarding victims of abuse, neglect, or domestic violence. Rather, the NPRM addressed disclosures about child abuse pursuant to proposed § 164.510(b), which would have allowed covered entities to report child abuse to a public health authority or to another appropriate authority authorized by law to receive reports of child abuse or neglect. We respond to comments regarding victims of domestic violence or abuse throughout the final rule where relevant. (See responses to comments on §§ 164.502(g), 164.510(b), 164.512(f)(3), 164.522, and 164.524.)

Comment: Several commenters urged us to require that victims of domestic violence be notified about requests for or disclosures of protected health information about them, so that victims could take safety precautions.

Response: We agree that, in balancing the burdens on covered entities from such a notification requirement against the benefits to be gained, victims of domestic abuse merit heightened concern. For this reason, we generally require covered entities to inform the individual when they disclose protected health information to authorized government authorities. As the Family Violence Prevention Fund has noted in its Health Privacy Principles for Protecting Victims of Domestic Violence (October 2000), victims of domestic violence and abuse sometimes are subject to retaliatory violence. By informing a victim of abuse or domestic violence of a disclosure to law enforcement or other authorities, covered entities give victims the opportunity to take appropriate safety precautions. See the above preamble discussion of § 164.512(c) for more detail about the requirements for disclosing protected health information about victims of domestic violence.

Comment: Some commenters argued that a consent requirement should apply at a minimum to disclosures involving victims of crime or victims of domestic violence.

Response: We agree, and we modify the proposed rule to require covered entities to obtain an individual's agreement prior to disclosing protected health information in most instances involving victims of a crime or of abuse, neglect, or domestic violence. See the above preamble discussions of § 164.512(c), on disclosures about victims of abuse, neglect, or domestic violence, and § 164.512(f)(3), on disclosures to law enforcement about crime victims.