Standards for Privacy of Individually Identifiable Health Information. Final Privacy Rule Preamble.. Disclosure Tracking and History


The final rule requires providers to be able to produce a record of all disclosures of protected health information, except in certain circumstances. The exceptions include disclosures for treatment, payment, health care operations, or disclosures to an individual. This requirement will require a notation in the record (electronic or paper) of when, to whom, and what information was disclosed, as well as the purpose of such disclosure or a copy of an individual's written authorization or request for a disclosure.

Based on information from several hospital sources, the Department assumes that all hospitals already track disclosures of individually identifiable health information and that 15 percent of all patient records held by a hospital will have an annual disclosure that will have to be recorded in an individual's record. It was more difficult to obtain a reliable estimate for non-hospital providers, though it appears that they receive many fewer requests. The Department assumed a ten percent rate for ambulatory care patients and five percent, for nursing homes, home health, dental and pharmacy providers. (It was difficult to obtain any reliable data for these latter groups, but those we talked to said that they had very few, and some indicated that they currently keep track of them in the records.) These estimated percentages represent about 63 million disclosures that will have to be recorded in the first year, with each recording estimated to require two minutes. At the average nurse's salary of $30.39 per hour, the cost in the first year is $25.7 million. For health plans, the Department assumed that disclosures of protected health information are more rare than for health care providers. Therefore, the Department assumed that there will be disclosures of protected health information for five percent of covered lives. At the average wage for the insurance industry of $33.82 per hour, the initial cost for health plans is $6.8 million. Using our standard growth rates for wages, patients, and covered entities, the ten-year cost for providers and health plans is $519 million.

In addition, although hospitals generally track patient disclosures today, the Department assumes that hospitals will seek to update software systems to assure full compliance. Based on software upgrade costs provided by the Department's private sector consultants with expertise in the area (the Gartner Group), the Department assumed that each upgrade would cost $35,000 initially and $6,300 annually thereafter, for a total cost of $572 million over ten years.

The final rule also requires covered entities to provide individuals with an accounting of disclosures upon request. The Department assumes that few patients will request a history of disclosures of their protected medical information. Therefore, we estimate that one in a thousand patients will request such an accounting each year, which is approximately 850,000 requests. If it takes an average of five minutes to copy any disclosures and the work is done by a nurse, the cost will for the first year will be $2.1 million. The total ten-year cost is $33.8 million.